Saturday, March 1, 2014

Sander Levin embraces tax reform



With a lifetime of public service that includes  32 years in Congress, Sander Levin knows a good thing when he sees it.

And he thinks colleague Dave Camp is onto something good with his comprehensive tax reform proposal.

Camp and Levin share something in common — their membership on the Ways and Means Committee of the U.S. House of Representatives.

Camp, a member of the House’s Republican majority, is chairman of the committee  and Levin is the ranking Democrat. Levin was chairman of the committee when Democrats last held a majority in the House, prior to 2011.

They also are both from Michigan, Camp hailing from Midland and Levin from Royal Oak.

Camp has been working on his plan for three years, and has held hearings across the country. He also has attempted to design it to win bipartisan support.

Otherwise, why work on it at all? The only reasons would be purely partisan, and if that were the case it wouldn’t be worthy of any attention at all.

Levin thinks the plan has some merit. He issued the following statement:

 “Chairman Camp’s tax reform proposal opens up a discussion that Democrats have wanted to engage in on a bipartisan basis. As Democrats, we believe it is vital that tax reform encourage economic growth, support working families, broaden the middle class, and address income inequality. It must produce a fairer and more adequate tax code for all Americans, ensuring that wealthy individuals and corporations pay their fair share while preserving our long-term economic security in a fiscally responsible way that promotes jobs in the United States. It is through the lens of those priorities that we will review Chairman Camp’s proposal in detail as the Committee undertakes a thorough examination of his proposal.”

Well, we should all hope there will be serious consideration. Much of it is just pure common sense, regardless of whether you are a Republican or Democrat.

Perhaps it is too much to hope that it would stand  a chance in this political year, but hope springs eternal. And springtime is right around the corner.


Tuesday, February 25, 2014

Michigan test concerns superintendents

A new statewide testing system for Michigan’s public school students appears to be in the works, but superintendents are expressing some concern.

The system would be aligned with the Common Core standards for math and reading that the legislature approved last year.

The state Department of Education has contracts ready to implement something called the Smarter Balanced assessment system, but the fact that it would be new to students is worrying some school officials.

Among companies that have testing materials available, Smarter Balanced has been endorsed by the Michigan Assessment Consortium as most appropriate for the state. The Education Trust-Midwest, a statewide education research, information and advocacy organization also has endorsed Smarter Balanced.

A statement issued by superintendents from Macomb, Oakland and Wayne counties said that while Smarter Balanced meets a number of desirable criteria, “it is unclear whether or not Michigan has done sufficient field testing to assure accurate and adequate implementation of this new assessment system. Also, there are parts of the system still under development. We recommend due diligence on the state’s part before implementing and then using this new assessment system for accountability purposes.”

“I don’t have the confidence it’s going to be done right. Too much emphasis is put on one assessment,” said Riverview Superintendent Russell Pickell, echoing the formal statement by the superintendents.

“We believe a statewide assessment applied to every student in every grade needs to be carried out ONLY because it is required by the federal government in order to receive federal funds,” the superintendents said. “If not for that, we would not support a single statewide test given every year to every student for accountability purposes. If federal rules allowed, we believe that the state could accurately inform itself as to the progress of students on the standards via state-developed benchmark testing which could be done at three grade levels (such as 4,7,10) with a random sample of students.”

Pickell also questioned “the amount of time these tests take.” He said the state is being rushed into the new system because of deadlines.

He worries about how the test results will be used, and pointed out that it is so technology dependent — i.e., can only be taken online — some scores “may have nothing to do with achievement.”

The first time the test is used it can do nothing more than establish a baseline, Pickell said.
Wyandotte School Superintendent Carla Harting also indicated support for the concerns raised in the statement by the superintendents from the three counties.

The superintendents from the three counties acknowledged they appear to have no choice.

Earlier this month, officials from the Education Trust-Midwest addressed the legislature to voice support of the state’s plans to implement the new college- and career-ready state assessment system.

“Michigan’s new assessment system will provide us a powerful driver to transform our public schools’ teaching and learning — and ensure all of our students are college- and career-ready for today’s globally competitive knowledge economy,” said Amber Arellano, executive director of ETM.

However, ETM cautioned against state leaders allocating budget money to be used to support one state assessment for educator evaluations and to measure student performance, and another to measure student growth for school accountability purposes.

“Such a move would result in unnecessary additional testing time for students, and unnecessary and significant additional costs for the state to bear,” Arellano said.

“Our state’s planned new assessment system will generate far more reliable, helpful student growth data than Michigan has ever had,” said Sarah Lenhoff, director of policy and research for ETM. “These rich new data will help educators and schools tailor interventions and learning strategies for students, even in their K-3 years. If developed and funded appropriately, we will have such a system in place by spring of 2015.”

“This is a game-changer for our state,” Arellano said.

Tuesday, February 18, 2014

Michigan tax relief certain, but what form will it take?

That some Michigan residents will be getting a tax cut is virtually certain. The form it takes is very much up in the air, however, despite Gov. Rick Snyder’s support for a partial restoration of the Homestead Property Tax Credit.

Many Republicans are not happy with Snyder’s proposal, which would permanently raise the income cutoff for the Homestead Property Tax Credit to $60,000, still short of the $82,650 threshold that existed before the governor took office in 2011.

Snyder felt that tax relief should be targeted for lower- and middle-income families. His proposal would mean an estimated 1.3 million taxpayers would pay $103 million less in taxes in year one, equaling about $79 per filing, according to an Associated Press report.

State Rep. Patrick Somerville (R-Huron Twp.) indicated he would favor something that is broader based. He worries about “further complicating the tax code.”

Somerville instead favors a plan that would reduce the income tax from its current 4.25 percent to 4.15 percent on Oct. 1; to 4.05 percent in October of next year; and possibly to 3.95 percent the year after if the state has a surplus of $300 million or more at the time.

Pension tax relief also might be in order, he said.

Sen. Patrick Colbeck (R-Canton) said his first concern is the condition of Michigan’s roads, but he concedes there may be room for tax reduction. Colbeck, whose district includes eight communities in the southern portion of Downriver, said he likes “the idea of reducing property taxes,” and he also thinks that “promoting charities is a good way to help the poor.”

To that end, he indicated he would support an increase in the limit for charitable tax deductions. Colbeck feels the private sector is more effective in helping the underprivileged than the public sector.

Democratic lawmakers questioned for this colum did not respond, but Rep. Andrew Kandrevas of Southgate last year endorsed a Democratic plan to restore tax credits and deductions to middle-class families and repeal new taxes on retirees.

In a statement on his website, State Sen. Hoon-Yung Hopgood (D-Taylor) said “the governor’s incomplete restoration of the Homestead Property Tax Credit pales in comparison to the thousands of dollars in additional taxes he has placed on Michigan families, and his budget continues to rely on taxes on retirement income and the elimination of the child deduction and the reduction of the Earned Income Tax Credit.

“The proposed increased income threshold to qualify for the Homestead Property Tax Credit remains far below what it was before it was slashed by the governor earlier in his term, leaving thousands of middle class families unable to qualify for it and paying higher taxes as a result.”

Democrats have been consistent in their criticism of the governor and the legislature for raising taxes on individuals while cutting them on businesses in 2011.

Colbeck said it is certainly nice to be talking about a $1 billion surplus as opposed to the $1.5 billion deficit that faced lawmakers and Snyder in 2011.

“It’s tough to say what will pass,” Somerville said. It could be a “combination of everything.” He called the situation a “moving puzzle,” but said there should be enough in the surplus to provide significant tax relief, increase funding for roads and schools and set aside a rainy day fund in the range of $750 million.

There’s still time for taxpayers to weigh in. They should email their state representatives and senators.

Monday, February 10, 2014

What's wrong with retirement, part-time work?


The Affordable Care Act will lead to the equivalent of 2 million fewer jobs by 2024, according to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office, but that does NOT mean Obamacare is causing more unemployment.

These are people leaving the job market. Why is that a bad thing?

Many of these are folks who will be retiring early because with the ACA they can now rely on themselves to get health coverage instead of being dependent on their employer.

Again, why is this a bad thing?

Yet Rush Limbaugh is leading the charge among Obamacare critics by saying the law is turning people into “wards of the state.”

“You take away the desire, necessity, to work, you're effectively dehumanizing people,” Limbaugh said on his radio program.   “You are taking away from many people one of the primary sources of their confidence, self-identity, reason for being, particularly in men, but in more and more women now with feminism and so forth making its giant strides.  It's just a tragic thing here that's happening, and it's turning more and more people into satisfied wards of the state.”

What does he mean?  Are Social Security recipients wards of the state? This sounds a bt like Mitt Romney’s damaging remark about the 47 percent of the populace who are dependent on government.

Well, we’re all dependent on government in one fashion or another. It is what it is. The horse is out of the barn. You couldn’t turn the clock back if you wanted to.

But what’s going on here is very simple.

Previous to the ACA, people were dependent on their employers for health care, which in most cases they could only get by working fulltime. Everybody knows people who hold jobs solely because they need health insurance.

With ACA there are now choices. Many people are able to get their own health insurance at very low rates, especially if they qualify for the generous subsidies that are part of the law. As a result, many will opt to retire early or cut back to part-time status.

Retirements create job openings. The quicker older people leave the workforce the quicker opportunities will be created for younger people. Instead of a drag on productivity, energetic young people  could stimulate economic output.

ACA foes quickly — and erroneously — seized on the CBO report as proof that Obamacare is a job killer.  People can decide for themselves whether what is going on is a good or bad thing, but some of us feel that early retirement or cutting back on our hours is the door to our opportunity at this particular stage of our lives.

Limbaugh and his ilk can say that taking advantage of ACA subsidies or drawing Social Security benefits earlier rather than later makes people “wards of the state,” but the alternative, in some cases, is working in a virtual sweatshop. Limbaugh apparently thinks it’s a good thing to be stuck in a job you don’t want.

Money and careers are not the only things in life. There are other — some of us think finer — values in life: family, travel, fitness and volunteer activities, for instance.

What  do you think?



Saturday, February 8, 2014

Bipartisan measure could rebuild nation's roads, infrastructure


Taxpayers should encourage their federal lawmakers to support the Partnership to Build America Act so Michigan — and every other state, for that matter — can improve its roads.

The measure, officially House Resolution 2084, would create the American Infrastructure Fund to pay for the rebuilding of our country’s transportation, energy, communications, water and education infrastructure.

More than that, it would create incentives for companies to invest at home rather than abroad.

The AIF would be funded by the sale of $50 billion in bonds that would  have a 50-year term, pay a fixed interest rate of 1 percent, and would not be guaranteed by the U.S. government, according to a website explaining the program.

U.S. corporations would be incentivized to purchase these new infrastructure bonds by allowing them to repatriate a certain amount of their overseas earnings tax free for every $1 they invest in the bonds. 

The AIF could leverage the $50 billion of bonds at a 15:1 ratio to provide up to $750 billion in loans or guarantees.

The AIF would provide loans or guarantees to state or local governments to finance qualified infrastructure projects. The states or local governments would be required to pay back the loan at a market rate determined by the AIF, but this is something states would have a hard time doing on their own. There would be no federal taxpayer obligation.

HR 2084 was introduced last year by U.S. Rep. John Delaney, a Democrat from Maryland. It is a rare bipartisan measure in Congress, with 50 co-sponsors in the House of Representatives evenly divided between the two parties.

It was also introduced in the U.S. Senate last month by a small bipartisan group of senators.

Sadly  — incredibly, actually — none of the sponsors is from Michigan. That’s a shame because Michigan’s highway needs are plain for all drivers to see everyday.

A report released last month by TRIP, a national transportation research group, said Michigan’s bad roads cost the state’s residents
approximately $7.7 billion annually in the form of additional
vehicle operating costs, lost time and wasted fuel due to traffic congestion and traffic crashes.

That translates to an individual cost of $1,600 for Detroit area drivers, where 57 percent of major roadways are in poor or mediocre  condition.

Plus, highway conditions are critical to economic development.

“Increasingly, companies are looking at the quality of a region’s transportation system when deciding where to relocate or expand,” the TRIP study said. “Regions with congested or poorly maintained roads may see businesses relocate to areas with a smoother, more efficient and more modern transportation system.”

Our federal lawmakers need to hear from citizens. They need to put Michigan’s interests ahead of any narrow partisan considerations.


CBO underscores need to address national debt


It was just one paragraph in a 182-page report, but it was arguably the most important.

Predictably, it received virtually no media attention.

The Congressional Budget office’s non-partisan study on “The Budget and Economic Outlook: 2014 to 2024” said that “the large budget deficits recorded in recent years have substantially increased federal debt, and the amount of debt relative to the size of the economy is now very high by historical standards.

“CBO estimates that federal debt held by the public will equal 74 percent of GDP at the end of this year and 79 percent in 2024 (the end of the current 10-year projection period).”

And the consequences? They are potentially dire, according to CBO.

“Such large and growing federal debt could have serious negative consequences, including restraining economic growth in the long term, giving policymakers less flexibility to respond to unexpected challenges, and eventually increasing the risk of a fiscal crisis (in which investors would demand high interest rates to buy the government’s debt).”

And yet what CBO had to say on the impact of Obamacare got most of the attention.

Our government needs to address out $17-trillion-plus national debt while there is still time to avoid potential disaster.

Thursday, February 6, 2014

Fight bipartisan plan to tax Medigap


Senior citizens face the fight of their lives over Medicare and it’s  a battle they need to prepare themselves to wage.

For some time there has been bipartisan support to tax Medigap policies in order to control Medicare,  but now a new study is giving ammunition to advocates of this approach.

Bipartisanship is a great thing and extolled here at “Between Extremes.” But not this type of bipartisanship.

Chuck Austin of Oakland County (Mich.), head of the SeniorNews and Advocacy Coalition, called our attention to the study by University of Chicago and University of Texas researchers that claims Medigap policies are adding 22 percent annually to Medicare costs.  They propose a 15 percent tax on Medigap policies to discourage their use.

Medigap is supplemental private insurance senior citizens purchase to pick up expenses that  Medicare fails to cover. Medicare only covers 80 percent of most expenses and there is no out-of-pocket maximum on medical costs that individuals may incur.

Think of it. Without Medigap, senior citizens with serious illnesses such as older people normally suffer would end up in the poorhouse.

There is no disputing the figures the researchers came up with. But there is insufficient evidence to show that the costs are not covering vital health services, which, of course, is the whole purpose of Medicare.

"They can say nothing at all about whether that utilization is life-saving cancer care or discretionary back surgery," Bruce Vladeck, who ran Medicare under President Clinton,  told Kaiser Health News. "Maybe it would be a good paper in a graduate econometrics course, but it just doesn't reflect reality."

To be sure, Medicare expenses need to be controlled. But there are many other ways to do so, and many common-sense policies were advocated  by the President’s National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform in 2010.

But the idea of a 15 percent tax on Medigap policies is outrageous. Yet the idea of a tax or surcharge is supported by both President Obama and House Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan, according to KHN.

Senior citizens need to brace themselves to fight to protect their life savings.