Monday, January 20, 2014

Bills would curb police right to seize your assets


Did you know that under Michigan’s civil forfeiture laws, someone does not have to be convicted of or even charged with a crime to permanently lose his or her cash, car or home to law enforcement?

Two Michigan lawmakers want to do something about it and have scheduled a meeting at 7 p.m. Thursday, Jan. 23 to inform the public about the issue.

State Reps. Tom McMillin, R-Rochester Hills, and Rep. Jeff Irwin, D-Ann Arbor, are both sponsoring legislation to curb the practice.

Thurday’s meeting on "Civil Asset Forfeiture Laws and Reforms" will be held at the Royal Oak Public Library. 

Speakers will include McMillin, Rep. Rose Mary Robinson, D-Detroit,
Shelli Weisberg, legislative director of the Michigan chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union, and Dennis Marburger, the Oakland County coordinator of the Michigan Campaign  for Liberty.

McMillin called civil asset forfeiture reform an issue that crosses the political spectrum of left and right.

“Taking a citizen’s assets without a conviction certainly seems unfair,” McMillin said in a press release.

Irwin’s HB 5212 would require a conviction before citizens' assets could be kept. McMillin’s HB 5081  would bring transparency to the process. If passed, for the first time Michigan citizens could see how often people's assets are taken without a conviction and how the funds are used, among other disclosures, McMillin said.

According to a 2010 Institute for Justice study, Michigan has one of the worst civil asset forfeiture laws in the nation.

Michigan  earned a D- from the institute in its report “Policing for Profit.” Currently, the government has to establish by a “preponderance of the evidence” that a property was involved in criminal activity to forfeit property, according to the institute. That is a much lower evidentiary standard than what’s required for a criminal conviction, which is “beyond a reasonable doubt.”

So if HB 5213 is enacted, it would raise the bar, meaning prosecutors would need far more evidence to engage in forfeiture, according to the institute.

Michigan has recently witnessed several high-profile civil forfeiture cases. Two Detroit-area small business owners, Terry Dehko and Mark Zaniewski, had their entire bank accounts seized by the IRS, even though neither was charged with any crime, according to the institute. Over $100,000 in total was taken from the two men.

An even more controversial incident occurred when Detroit police raided and seized cars at an art gala.  


Saturday, January 18, 2014

Land may be competitive with Peters in Michigan U.S. Senate race


U.S. Rep. Gary Peters, a Democrat from Bloomfield Township, has been considered a heavy favorite to win the U.S. Senate seat of retiring Carl Levin. But his Republican foe, former Michigan Secretary of State Terri Lynn Land is leading in three consecutive polls since last month.

The most recent is the respected Rasmussen Reports poll, which shows Land leading by 2 percentage points, 37 to 35 percent.

The Harper Poll showed her with a 44 to 36 percent lead on Jan. 13 and  Public Policy Polling gave her a 42-40 lead last month.

Referring to the Harper Poll, RedState’s Moe Lane said “it’s early, it’s one of a bunch of possible outcomes, it’s a Republican pollster (Harper), and so forth. But this is still pretty good news for Republican candidate Terri Lynn Land. And the Republican party in Michigan, because Harper also checked the generic race.”

While that showed Democrats leading by 1 percentage point, Land’s favorable-unfavorable rating was 32-18 percent with Peters at 18-18.

It would be foolish to underestimate Peters. Not only is he a brilliant campaigner, but Republicans crossed over in sizeable number to elect him to Congress from an Oakland County district in 2008 and re-elect him in 2010.  He was forced to run in a much more liberal district in 2012 due to redistricting, and his pronouncements since then have taken on a more partisan cast.

Peters is well informed on financial and budget-related issues and is Michigan’s former lottery commissioner. He ran for statewide office in 2002, losing to Mike Cox in the race for attorney general. A decorated Navy veteran, he served in the Persian Gulf War. 

Land was not the first choice of Michigan’s GOP party professionals. That designation went to U.S. Rep. Mike Rogers, who decided to instead seek re-election.

Her prowess as a campaigner in a contest like this one is untested, and while she is raising substantial amount of money for the campaign, she has been slow on the draw in terms of setting up the apparatus of a campaign.

The point is, a race thought to lean Democratic may actually turn out to be competitive. 

Friday, January 17, 2014

Rick Snyder tiptoes onto national scene


For Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder, it was a bold move.

He asked the legislature to pass a resolution urging Congress to initiate an amendment to the U.S. Constitution requiring the federal government to balance its budget.

It is an old idea. But for Snyder, who eschews national politics, it was his version of outspoken. He made the comments in his annual state-of-the-state address.

It comes four months after the governor told the Associated Press he hopes he is “a reasonable model for people to look at across the country."

Unlike his colleagues among Republican governors, Snyder rarely wades into national political waters. Nevertheless, some say he could become more active after he dispenses with challenger Mark Schauer, his Democratic challenger, in November’s governor’s race.  That appears an all-but-certain outcome.

No one would dispute that Michiganians are better off than when Snyder took office in January of 2011.

He carefully avoided specifics in his state-of-the-state address, but called for tax relief and more spending on roads  and schools. Details will come as he presents his budget in the coming weeks.

Thursday, January 16, 2014

Time to put Benghazi behind us

A new U.S. Senate report on the September 2012 attack on U.S. diplomatic facilities in Benghazi, Libya, in which an American diplomat and three others were killed, ought to lay the issue to rest.

The attack has been investigated backwards and forwards. Turns  out almost everyone shares blame for the humiliating terrorist assault, not the least of which ought to be the American people who elected the administration in charge at the time and then re-elected it two months after the assault.

The bipartisan report blames the Central Intelligence Agency, the State Department and even the ambassador himself, J. Christopher Stevens, who rejected protection from the Pentagon shortly before the attack.

The report is reassuring evidence that our government can still do commendable investigative report in spite of the partisan rancor that divides Washington.
 
The Benghazi attack has been amply probed by the State Department, CIA and Congress. Four State Department officials were suspended in the aftermath of the killings.

People who want to blame former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton now have solid evidence of her shortcomings. But so what? She long ago accepted responsibility  and numerous necessary changes have been and are being made in the department. If further accountability is necessary the public just may have that chance if she runs for president in 2016.

There is nothing left to say. People made mistakes. Guess what? Security was insufficient at Pearl Harbor in 1941 but the American people continued to support President Roosevelt anyway.

 Any charges of conspiracy by Fox News or anyone else tied to Benghazi are baseless. The facts are now out there for everyone to see — as they should be.







 

Wednesday, January 15, 2014

AARP's rival has good Social Security plan


A group that brands itself as a rival to AARP is pushing non-partisan reforms to Social Security that Congress ought to consider. 

Although the  seven-year-old Association of Mature American Citizens calls itself a conservative alternative, the group’s proposal lacks the privatization features that have doomed other plans advanced by groups on the right side of the political spectrum.

AMAC might do better if it eschewed political labels because, in fact, its proposals are voted on by the group’s membership, using a tool that ensures that members can only vote once.

“Our members choose the issues and drive the agenda,” said Andy Mangione, AMAC’s vice president for governmental relations. 

And members have overwhelmingly chosen Social Security and its future as their major concern.

“People don’t save enough for retirement — we know that,” Mangione said.

AMAC’s proposal, for which Mangione has been lobbying on Capitol Hill, takes a two-pronged approach. The first facet would maintain the same or increased benefits for those with lower earnings and the second would   provide a means for all earners to have more income available at retirement.

 It would guarantee cost-of-living adjustments to Social Security recipients annually, using a tiered approach to calculating the COLA. No increases were granted in 2009 and 2010, even though gasoline and food prices rose.

  For beneficiaries with a household income  level less than $20,000,  COLAs would range from a 3 to 4 percent increase..

 For beneficiaries with a household income  between $20,001 and $50,000, the COLA range would be 1.5 to 3 percent.

For beneficiaries with a household income  of $50,001 or higher, the COLA range would be from 1 to 2 percent.

AMAC’s plan also would phase in a change in the earliest retirement age. Starting in 2016, it would add three months each year so that by 2023 it would be 64 instead of the current 62.

Starting in 2017, it would phase in a change to the normal retirement age by adding three months each year so that by 2024, it would be 69 instead of the current 66 to 67, which depends on the birth year.

AMAC’s plan also would lower benefits for higher income earners while maintaining the same benefits for those with less income, beginning in 2019.

The current annual Social Security trustee report projects a shortfall in the program’s trust fund of 4.5 percent in 75 years. If AMAC’s proposals were adopted, there would be a surplus of .17 percent.

Meanwhile, the plan also calls for a voluntary, portable tax-deferred Early Retirement Account program implemented through employers. It would allow the employee to set aside up to $5,200 annually and the employer to contribute up to $2,600 annually. Both employees and employers would be eligible for tax deductions.

Unlike 401K plans, which are routinely tapped into for a variety of reasons, the ERA would not be available until retirement. Enrollees could accumulate up to $354,000, Mangione said.

AMAC’s common-sense proposals apparently are catching on. Membership is growing by 40,000 every month, and has doubled to about 1.1 million from 500,000 in 2012. AMAC seeks to designate representatives from each  of the nation’s 435 congressional districts and eventually hopes to organize state chapters.

AMAC membership costs $16 annually and is available on the organizations’s website at amac.us. Anyone over the age of 50 may join and 40 percent of the group’s members are not retired.

Dan Weber, a family business owner in New York, founded AMAC because he felt the other major 50+ organizations were too liberal and did not represent his views.

But Mangione emphasizes that only members can set the agenda, and they are polled on a weekly basis. The group does not support candidates and has met with 140 members of Congress from both parties.

“We will meet with anybody,” Mangione said.

AMAC’s Social Security reforms should appeal to everyone. They include incentives to save, protection for those with lower incomes, modest restraints for everyone and small reductions in benefits for those with higher incomes.

Congress and the public should rally behind these ideas.



Tuesday, January 14, 2014

ACA enrollment figures are encouraging


Young people either are or aren’t signing up in sufficient numbers to balance costs in the new insurance market created by the Affordable Care Act, depending on which partisan source you are believing.

The best factual source, however, is Kaiser Health News (kaiserhealthnews.org), which deals only in the facts.

KHN reported that “nearly a quarter of the 2.2 million people who have enrolled in health coverage in the health law’s insurance marketplaces are young adults — the population that’s hardest to reach and yet most vital for the financial stability of the new exchanges.”

That about sums it up.

"More than 6 million Americans have now either signed up for a private health insurance plan through the Marketplace or for Medicaid coverage," Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius said.

"Through December, 30 percent of those who enrolled were under age 35, with 24 percent being between the ages of 18 and 34 — consistent with the proportion of the population in this age group and in keeping with where Massachusetts enrollment was at this point," Sebelius reported. "More importantly, it is a sign of a clear demand for health insurance."

Commenting on the data, U.S. Rep Sander Levin of Royal Oak, ranking Democrat on the House Ways and Means Committee, pointed out that:

• 54 percent of those who have signed up are women and 46 percent are men;

• 30 percent are age 34 and under;

• 79 percent selected a plan with financial assistance.

KHN reported that a recent survey by the Coomonwealth Fund, a non-partisan research group, found that 41 percent of those who had shopped on state marketplaces were ages 19 to 34.

Meanwhile, "a study in November by the Kaiser Family Foundation )KHN us an editorially independet program of the foundation), downplayed concerns about so-called death spiral if not enough young people enrolled. Under a worst-case scenario in which just 25 percent of enrollees are age 18 to 34, then insurers would have to raise premiums by just 2.4 percent in 2015.

The bottom line is that Obamacare is here to stay. It won't be repealed. If it needs to be improved, let's fix it.










Monday, January 13, 2014

Detroit police chief touts value of responsible armed citizenry


It is almost impossible to have a rational discussion about gun control. Many people sincerely and honestly believe that a more restrictive policy toward gun ownership will curb cataclysmic occurrences such as the killing of 26 people at Sandy Hook School in Newtown, Ct. in December of 2012.

That’s why Detroit Police Chief James Craig gained such attention as he suggested a responsibly armed citizenry helps lower crime rates.

“A well-armed, good citizen can be the biggest deterrent to violent crime,” Craig told Fox News.

“Research bears this out,” Craig said, and he has  the statistics to back it up. There has been a 7 percent drop in violent crime in what has been characterized as the nation’s most violent cities. There has been a 14 percent drop in homicides and an 8 percent drop in non-fatal shootings

“Responsibility plays a key role here,” he added.

Craig cited a Department of Justice study that he said suggested “that a well-armed good citizen can be the biggest deterrent to violent crime.”

Craig, who has worked in four cities, said he used to routinely deny requests for concealed-carry weapons permits. He said he experienced an “aha moment” when he was chief in Portland, Me., where crime rates were low and the number of CCW permits was relatively high.

“Violent criminals here know their biggest fear is being met with an armed citizen,” Craig told Fox News. “They are more fearful of an armed citizen than of a police officer.”

Craig said some criminals in Detroit have taken to wearing body armor as a result.

Perhaps the answer lies in all sides agreeing to a responsible concealed-carry strategy. Until mental health is tackled as  a serious issue, tragedies such as occurred in Sandy Hook may continue, and tilting at the gun control windmill is unlikely to be productive as a strategy to counter them.

Links: